Why do I even bother checking my stats? No one reads this! I suppose that is in part why I enjoy writing here because I enjoy the feeling of anonymity that I feel. Though sometimes I resent it at the same time. Am I just sabotaging my own happiness? Ah well....probably.
So I watched a movie yesterday. Because why work or study when you can just waste your time filling your head with the creative expressions of artistic visions of others....AAAAAH! Anyway though, I watched a movie called 'Donnie Brasco.' It's a pretty well known film from the early '90's about an undercover cop who infiltrates a mob. The film was pretty complicated and I am not sure how I feel about it as a whole, but one thing that I had a strong and immediate response to was the scenes where the undercover cop interacted with his children.
I was trying to explain to Masako yesterday who strange it felt to have such a strong emotional response to such a small thing, but I was not able to really get anything of any sense out. Part of the movie and the struggle of the main character was his desire to be with his family but that he was not able to. Or in other words, the damage that his job was doing to his relationship with his wife and children. There was one particular scene in which the main guy is just in his daughters' room as they are sleeping. He is patting their hair and the oldest wakes up a little bit and he asks her a few questions about who she is and her relationship with God.
I'm not sure if this small scene was supposed to be significant in any way, but it absolutely moved me to tears which tells me either (or both) of two things: I am getting more emotional with age, and that I am worried about my current and future relationship with my children. I am not sure which applies. I never used to cry at such small moments. There was no dramatic swell of music or closeup of tears on the face. It was so small. But I just couldn't help it. It surprised me.
As for my current place in life, I am starring down the barrel of a new job with the Air Force which is going to mean time away from my family in training and commitments to performing jobs of import. Like the main character of the movie, I hope that what I will be embarking on will be of some importance or that at the very least that I will be doing something worth doing. But what I am afraid of is that I will lose the balance that is required in life and that I will not dedicate the time and energy necessary to cultivate my family the way it needs.
Maybe the reason I felt so moved by the scene was the fact that the daughter answered the questions correctly. I have no doubt that I will have similar discussions with my children. Multiple times even. Will they know the correct answers to the questions of who they are? Who God is? Or their relationship to God? Will they know how much I love them and want them to be happy? Will I be able to instill upon them the burning desire to live the best kind of life possible? To live on purpose? To live deeply and suck out all the marrow of life? I'm tearing up a bit now just thinking about it.
There is no greater responsibility in the world than what I feel is my duty to teach my children the answers to these questions. I hope and pray that I will not fail in that quest.
In this blog, it is my intention to share my thoughts, experiences, ponderings, philosophies, doubts, insecurities, and curiosities with whomever would like to read. I am fascinated by the idea of a connected world, and have a desire to play some part in it if I may.
Tuesday, May 26, 2015
Wednesday, May 20, 2015
Does Dissent Define Democracy?
I just watched a very interesting documentary about the Chinese artist Ai Weiwei. I was unfamiliar with this artist or his political dissidence but I found the documentary to be a very enlightening and compelling one. It was meant to be a one sided but powerful look at the issues that modern Chinese political activists are fighting for, in particular those of Mr. Weiwei. The documentary treated Mr. Weiwei's main issue as being a lack of transparency in the Chinese government, particularly in the treatment of statistics regarding death tolls for an earthquake which took place some years ago that resulted in the deaths of over 70,000 people, including an estimated 5,000 children whom it is suspected died while attending school in buildings built in a questionable manner. It was Mr. Weiwei's contention that the manner of the construction of these buildings should be a matter of public attention and discussion. However, the government in a very corrupt manner disagrees with his sentiment.
Whereas the film itself was rather compelling, it brought to my mind a question that I realized that I did not have an answer for and would like to explore. Does dissent define Democracy? Or to put it another way, what is the relationship between democracy and the act of dissent?
In the film, Mr. Weiwei is passionate in his pleas and quest for a greater sense of democracy in his native country. His chosen method for doing this involves passive and active acts of artistic and traditional protest against the government. His artistic sense, together with the respect he has garnished in the world through social media, have given him a powerful voice for publicizing his feelings of dissent. For this reason he is labeled by many and in particular those in this film as being a hero of democracy, or a symbol of democracy.
And he is not alone. In the US as well, most of the best known symbols of democracy were those who carried a voice of discontent. The founding fathers, the voices against the culture of slavery, freedom fighters in the south, women's rights activists particularly over the last 100 years, and many others have been held up as great examples of true democracy. And I personally believe that this is completely warranted.
One of the most important elements of democracy certainly is dissent! But is it at its center? The ability to fight verbally and morally against a state of affairs that is unacceptable to a person's sense of right lies at the very epicenter of the philosophical superiority of democracy over other historical forms of government. It is this ability to enact change without violence that I believe has given our modern society a chance to out-last and out-perform any society that has ever been established! I guess we will see given time whether my optimism is valid.
However is it only in dissent that true democracy is demonstrated? Is there an active performance of democracy or is it by definition only a reactionary one?
Maybe it is all reactionary. After all, democracy is nothing more than a system of government and government is not society. Government is supposed to be a tool of society for justice (what is Justice? A topic of such scale as to be way beyond this pondering....but maybe someday I'll get around to it). And maybe the tool of government in its ideal usage is one that only is in action when there is a problem that needs to be amended. Maybe to actively try to shape society in a way that is not broken in some way, that is not needing mending, is to invite nothing but destruction.
So I guess my conclusion for now is Yes, dissent IS at the core of democracy. Every vote that is cast is a dissent against the status quo. Whether that status quo is an elected leader or the idea of replacing an elected leader; whether to change society or protect its current state; the act of democracy is to fight against something.
To be honest, I don't know if I like that. Don't get me wrong, I love democracy and am a fervent defender of its ideals. I believe that the ability for a society to be able to decide for itself its own methods and direction is one of the most important precedents every established. But I wonder if there is not someone out there far more brilliant than I that has the ability to establish a form of constructive democracy not based merely on dissent. Democracy is dissent. Dissent is democracy. Is there no way to sever this seemingly negative relationship without it destroying the whole system? OR is my state of mind that dissent is necessarily a negative a mistaken assumption? Again I might be veering off topic but my conclusion is unsettling to me.
Whereas the film itself was rather compelling, it brought to my mind a question that I realized that I did not have an answer for and would like to explore. Does dissent define Democracy? Or to put it another way, what is the relationship between democracy and the act of dissent?
In the film, Mr. Weiwei is passionate in his pleas and quest for a greater sense of democracy in his native country. His chosen method for doing this involves passive and active acts of artistic and traditional protest against the government. His artistic sense, together with the respect he has garnished in the world through social media, have given him a powerful voice for publicizing his feelings of dissent. For this reason he is labeled by many and in particular those in this film as being a hero of democracy, or a symbol of democracy.
And he is not alone. In the US as well, most of the best known symbols of democracy were those who carried a voice of discontent. The founding fathers, the voices against the culture of slavery, freedom fighters in the south, women's rights activists particularly over the last 100 years, and many others have been held up as great examples of true democracy. And I personally believe that this is completely warranted.
One of the most important elements of democracy certainly is dissent! But is it at its center? The ability to fight verbally and morally against a state of affairs that is unacceptable to a person's sense of right lies at the very epicenter of the philosophical superiority of democracy over other historical forms of government. It is this ability to enact change without violence that I believe has given our modern society a chance to out-last and out-perform any society that has ever been established! I guess we will see given time whether my optimism is valid.
However is it only in dissent that true democracy is demonstrated? Is there an active performance of democracy or is it by definition only a reactionary one?
Maybe it is all reactionary. After all, democracy is nothing more than a system of government and government is not society. Government is supposed to be a tool of society for justice (what is Justice? A topic of such scale as to be way beyond this pondering....but maybe someday I'll get around to it). And maybe the tool of government in its ideal usage is one that only is in action when there is a problem that needs to be amended. Maybe to actively try to shape society in a way that is not broken in some way, that is not needing mending, is to invite nothing but destruction.
So I guess my conclusion for now is Yes, dissent IS at the core of democracy. Every vote that is cast is a dissent against the status quo. Whether that status quo is an elected leader or the idea of replacing an elected leader; whether to change society or protect its current state; the act of democracy is to fight against something.
To be honest, I don't know if I like that. Don't get me wrong, I love democracy and am a fervent defender of its ideals. I believe that the ability for a society to be able to decide for itself its own methods and direction is one of the most important precedents every established. But I wonder if there is not someone out there far more brilliant than I that has the ability to establish a form of constructive democracy not based merely on dissent. Democracy is dissent. Dissent is democracy. Is there no way to sever this seemingly negative relationship without it destroying the whole system? OR is my state of mind that dissent is necessarily a negative a mistaken assumption? Again I might be veering off topic but my conclusion is unsettling to me.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)